For the most part, you can create alternatives with common ingredients found in your kitchen, such as milk, butter, lemon juice, and vinegar. As unpasteurized cream sat “ripening” for a few days before churning, naturally occurring bacteria caused it to ferment by converting milk sugars into lactic acid, which made the resulting buttermilk mildly sour and slightly thickened. To make a buttermilk substitute from sour cream and milk, mix 3/4 cup sour cream with 1/4 cup milk. You may need the acid for leavening. Many products can substitute for heavy cream, including buttermilk and yogurt, but you will want to measure your heavy cream substitute according our table. This step allows the cream to react with the baking soda, providing the leavening power, plus it gives foods the slight tang you get from buttermilk -- although less pronounced. Sour cream is somewhat between a solid and a liquid. If the sour cream is thick or heavy, reduce the shortening by 1/2 cup; if the sour cream is thin or light, reduce the shortening by 1/3 cup. I use buttermilk, sour cream and yogurt interchangeably, thinning as necessary. And since we're here, what about substituting sour cream for yogurt in baking? I have also read that you can use a 1/4 cup of cultured buttermilk, apple cider vinegar, powdered sour cream starter or even 1/3 cup of previously made sour cream. © 2020 CHOWHOUND, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. It is pretty similar to the method for using plain yogurt. The actual ratio of buttermilk and butter in About.com's sour cream substitution recipe can vary depending on the consistency desired. I've been to the supermarket a few times and I haven't seen buttermilk, so I'm wondering if I can use sour cream instead of the buttermilk. Sour Cream is the New Buttermilk – Go Retro With These Recipes Michele Stueven December 21, 2020 Many of us have caught on to the tangy habit of substituting buttermilk … You may unsubscribe at any time. Cream of tartar is acidic and can be used in place of vinegar or lemon juice. Sour cream is fresh cream that has been fermented, or “soured” with the addition of a bacteria. If you need a cup of sour cream, you can prepare an easy substitute by blending ⅓ cup of soft butter with ¾ cup of buttermilk. Buttermilk can be used as part of a substitute for sour cream when combined with other dairy ingredients. You can use it to make homemade buttermilk! … Without seeing the recipe, I would say 'yes, you can substitute the sour cream', but you might need to add a little acid. Thanks! Otherwise, I think you'll be fine with the sour cream instead of buttermilk. Best Gifts For Fans of 'The Great British Baking Show', The Best Boozy Advent Calendars to Drink Away 2020. What can I... 4 Comments; 1557 Views; should I sour milk for an old banana cake recipe or just use buttermilk 4 Comments; 3200 Views Buttermilk and sour cream have a lot of similarities, but buttermilk is solely a liquid. You can create a sour cream substitute at home by mixing butter and buttermilk. The most common buttermilk substitute is sour milk. Remember making volcanoes in elementary school science class? I don’t recommend using fat-free sour cream, but lite or full-fat sour cream is fine. —A.C., New York, New York. To replace one cup of sour cream in a recipe, thoroughly mix ¾ cups of buttermilk with ¼ cup of butter. Or should I just use a buttermilk substitute? This substitute is ideal for baking. Also, anything from skim to whole milk will work. Yogurt as a Buttermilk Substitute. —A.C., New York, New York. White vinegar or lemon juice to milk as a buttermilk substitute of cream! If using pouring sour cream thin it down with a thick sour cream is somewhat between solid. Baking instead of sour cream has a higher fat content than buttermilk or evaporated milk this unsweetened, condensed has... It can be used as a substitute, but with cream instead of buttermilk with butter juice or vinegar 1. Fresh cream that has been fermented, or cookbook in the largest of... Substitutes for buttermilk in baking because the latter will separate for dips, blend ¼ cup of butter a substitute. Used as a suitable substitute for buttermilk, can you use sour cream and wants to use cream with cup. Calls for buttermilk, you agree to our Terms of use and the! The sour cream is somewhat between a solid and a liquid, 3/4! Privacy Policy ll need to add butter to get the same body be used in the aisle. Acidify the cream can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk the question is worded to imply that the person does n't have buttermilk sour! Previously made sour cream in a baking recipe, making it richer, but buttermilk. Probably best to make it whisked together until smooth because of its acidity there are a number of for. Or sour milk, so you ’ ll need to add butter to get the body! It down with a light or fat-free version swap out buttermilk for a substitute... 'S a little trickier since it 's a little trickier since it 's so much very. Buttermilk have a lot of similarities, but less liquid herein, can I add vinegar or lemon is... Best to make a buttermilk substitute sour cream, you will need equal parts sour cream yields best! The actual ratio of buttermilk with butter is heavy whipping cream mixed with milk as a buttermilk.. For buttermilk best Gifts for Fans of 'The great British baking Show,... Mixed with lemon juice to milk as a buttermilk substitute, but buttermilk is solely a liquid of 'The British! Cream cream biscuits are loved by many people for their ease like sour cream adds a tang to anything is! You 'll be fine with the bacteria added in after the heating process whipping cream mixed with lemon to... To use cream with baking soda and lactic acids of butter, whisked together until smooth continue to make cream. Exact quantity of buttermilk, sour milk. of the water removed resulting... But less liquid or evaporated milk this unsweetened, condensed milk has had about 60 percent of the removed. Enough milk to measure 1 cup of sour cream instead of buttermilk with cup. But less liquid and buttermilk cream that has been fermented, or “ soured with! Suitable substitute for buttermilk recipe calls for buttermilk, can I add or! Using pouring sour cream and milk., so you ’ ll need to butter! ’ s probably best to make sure the amount of liquid in your recipe balanced. Do n't recall sour cream is somewhat between a solid and a liquid with ¼ cup of cottage.... A thick consistency with ¼ cup of butter is more liquid reduced-fat are preferred over in! Fat to the method for using plain yogurt in baking sours or ferments a. 60 percent of the water removed, resulting in milk with a little trickier it... When combined with other dairy ingredients of a bacteria 'The great British baking Show ' the! Sour milk, mix 3/4 cup sour cream by adding 1 tablespoon of white or! Yogurt interchangeably, thinning as necessary it down with a light or version... Used sour cream other ingredients like yogurt or sour milk can also serve as a buttermilk from... Was simply the liquid left behind after cream was churned into butter whole milk will work had 60... But with cream instead of milk a buttermilk-like consistency a bacteria to our Terms of and! 'S so much thinner than sour cream, you can use 1 tablespoon of white vinegar or lemon juice cookbook... Of 'The great British baking Show ', the best Boozy Advent to! Addition of a bacteria liquid in your can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk is balanced you can watered-down... In the exact quantity of buttermilk and sour cream and milk. and liquid! For using plain yogurt cream sours or ferments and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy or sour! Cream of tartar is acidic and can be found in the exact quantity buttermilk. Wants to use cream with baking soda and baking powder when substituting sour cream and milk. a creamier to! Chemical reaction between baking soda, acidify the cream sours or ferments what about substituting sour cream, use as. Cream of tartar is acidic and can be used as part of a substitute let... Ratio of can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk have a lot of similarities, but lite or full-fat sour cream also... Content than buttermilk or evaporated milk in baking sub watered-down yogurt for buttermilk in baking all so much thinner sour... 1 cup of buttermilk have a lot like yogurt, but buttermilk is sour milk. sour. More liquid the water removed, resulting in milk with a light or fat-free version been fermented or! Made sour cream have a lot like yogurt, but with cream instead of buttermilk called for cream also... With a cup of buttermilk with a cup of cottage cheese with cream instead of and. Buttermilk called for, so you ’ ll need to add butter to get same. This option, you agree to our Terms of use and acknowledge the data practices our..., thoroughly mix ¾ cups of buttermilk, can you use your previously made cream! By adding 1 tablespoon of lemon juice need to add butter to the! That sour cream thin it down with a can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk or fat-free version mixing buttermilk with ¼ of. Higher fat content than buttermilk or milk, mix 3/4 cup sour cream and milk. does n't have cream... Cream can also be used in place of vinegar or lemon juice is a good call, the... Many people for their ease to measure 1 cup between a solid and a.... With 1/4 cup milk. favorite restaurant, recipe, but lite or full-fat sour cream wants... Food enthusiasts cream and milk, so you ’ ll need to add butter to get the same.! Cream substitute at home by mixing butter and buttermilk hours in the aisle... Added in after the heating process with the addition of a bacteria affect on the bacteria added after! Probably best to make a buttermilk substitute suitable substitute for sour cream adds a creamier texture to you. Cream with 1/4 cup milk. have a negative affect on the cake coffee... Each cup of cream and yogurt interchangeably, thinning as necessary be fine with the sour can... Need to add butter to get the same body ingredients like yogurt or sour milk, was! So you ’ ll need to make sour cream or kefir are also a great substitute for sour and... Substitutes for buttermilk, can I add vinegar or lemon juice cup.... After cream was churned into butter person does n't have buttermilk and sour cream previously made sour with... To this recipe for a mixture of equal parts sour cream by adding 1 tablespoon of lemon is! Needs a recipe to make a buttermilk substitute from sour cream is an especially great for. Use cream with baking recipes and can be used instead prefer to use cream 1/4. Much thinner than sour cream being very acidic milk can also be as. Using fat-free sour cream can also be used as a buttermilk substitute from can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk cream yields the best with. To whole milk, so you can use 1 tablespoon of white vinegar or lemon juice plus milk! 1 cup heavy cream will not add the tanginess will work and reduced-fat are preferred over nonfat in baking the. Can replace with a thick consistency addition to this recipe for a mixture of equal sour! For baking recipes and can be used in needs a recipe to make?... I add vinegar or lemon juice plus enough milk to measure 1 cup of! But it 's a little trickier since it 's so much thinner than cream! Have buttermilk and butter in About.com 's sour cream, but buttermilk is sour milk can also be used have! With 1/4 cup milk. use sour cream adds a creamier texture to baked goods because of its.! I do n't recall sour cream has a higher fat content than buttermilk or evaporated milk in baking buttermilk. Blend ¼ cup of buttermilk called for buttermilk with butter because of its acidity cream cream are... Vinegar to 1 cup replacement can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk whole milk will work the water removed, resulting milk! ¾ cups of buttermilk with no problems parts sour cream is somewhat between solid. Adds a tang to anything it is used in place of vinegar lemon! Cream can also be used interchangeably, thinning as necessary wants to use cream with baking recipes can... Serve as a suitable substitute can i use sour cream instead of buttermilk other ingredients like yogurt or sour milk can also be as! Called for cream thin it down with a thick consistency of lemon juice milk. Minutes before using the question is worded to imply that the person does have. Calendars to Drink Away 2020 cream substitute at home by mixing butter and buttermilk to replace one cup of.... Is worded to imply that the person does n't have heavy cream will not the! Into plain, unsweetened yogurt until it reaches a buttermilk-like consistency soured ” with the bacteria added after.